Ngaba 'uMunich: uMda weMfazwe' (2021) usekwe kwiBali eliyinyani?

IMunich-Isiphelo seMfazwe. UGeorge MacKay njengoHugh Legat, eMunich - uMda weMfazwe. Cr. Ngenkxaso yeNetflix © 2021

' UMunich: uMda weMfazwe ' ngumdlalo wezopolitiko owamiselwa ngo-1938 eYurophu kwiintsuku ezikhokelela IMfazwe Yehlabathi II .

Kulandela abahlobo ababini basekholejini abasebenza njengonozakuzaku kwaye mhlawumbi elona themba laseBritani lokuthintela imfazwe eyintlekele.

UChristian Schwochow (' NdinguKarl ’) yalathisa ifilimu, ebonisa isicwangciso esichulumancisayo esinemiba echulumancisayo kunye nobuntlola.

Ngenxa yokuba iziganeko zefilimu zenzeka kwiMfazwe Yehlabathi yesiBini kwaye zibandakanya iimbekiselo kwizinto ezininzi zobomi bokwenene bezopolitiko, abaphulaphuli baya kuba nomdla wokufunda ukuba isekelwe kuzo naziphi na iziganeko okanye iziganeko.

Nathi yasothusa le meko yaye sasifuna ukuphanda ngakumbi. Nantsi into ebesiyazi malunga 'neMunich: uMda weMfazwe'.

Bona kwakho: I-Movie yeDrama yeMbali 'i-Phantom Thread' (i-2017) Isiphelo esicacisiweyo

Ngaba 'uMunich: uMda weMfazwe' usekwe kwiBali eliyinyani?

Ezinye iindawo ze 'Munich: Umda weMfazwe' zisekelwe kwiziganeko eziyinyaniso. Ifilimu isekelwe kwinoveli ethengiswa kakhulu ' EMunich ,’ ngumbhali URobert Harris , eyaqala ukukhululwa ngo-2017.

Iploti yencwadi igxile kwiziganeko ezikhokelela Adolf Hitler 's 1938 Munich Isivumelwano kunye neNkulumbuso British uNeville Chamberlain.

Lo mgangatho uboniswa ngamehlo aBasebenzi bakaRhulumente uHugh Legat noPaul von Hartmann, ababekade befunda nabo eklasini.

Ifilimu yimveliso ethembekileyo yemithombo yomthombo, kunye nokuphambuka okumbalwa kwebali.

Nangona kunjalo, ukuze iphuhlise ibali layo, le ncwadi ixhomekeke ekubhaleni iziganeko ezenzeka ngokwenene kunye nokudala eyayo ingcaciso yembali.

UHarris uxoxe ngokudalwa kwencwadi kudliwanondlebe. Phantse iminyaka engamashumi amathathu, uHarris ebenomdla kwibali kunye nembali ejikeleze iSivumelwano saseMunich, ngokutsho kukaHarris.

Ngenxa ye @Robert___Harris 'Intengiso yamazwe ngamazwe, #MunichEdgeOfWar ugxile kubantwana ababini ababefunda nabo abazifumana sele bebandakanyeke kwiyelenqe lobuqhophololo lobupolitika njengoko uAdolf Hitler elungiselela ukuhlasela iCzechoslovakia. pic.twitter.com/SH2JqqbHcT

— Netflix ANZ (@NetflixANZ) NgoJanuwari 19, 2022

Wayenomdla wokufunda ngakumbi ngokubaluleka kwesivumelwano kwakunye neendima zeenkokeli zopolitiko ezibandakanyekileyo.

UHarris ucinge ngokusebenzisa into ukuba? Imeko yokuphanda ngeSivumelwano saseMunich kodwa ekugqibeleni bagqiba kwelokuba bajonge iinyani.

Wachaza ukuba injongo yesicwangciso senoveli yayikukunika abafundi enye imbono ngokubaluleka kweSivumelwano saseMunich kwimbali.

Emva kwengqungquthela eyayiphakathi kukaHitler, uChamberlain, uBenito Mussolini, noÉdouard Daladier ngowe-1938, kwatyikitywa iSivumelwano saseMunich.

Umnqweno kaHitler wokuhlasela iCzechoslovakia yeyona nto ibangela ukuba iinkokeli ezine zezopolitiko zihlangane ukuze kuxoxwe ngoxolo kuzo zombini iinoveli kunye nefilimu.

Nangona oku kuchanekile ngokwembali, ifilimu ayihoyi ezinye iziganeko, kunye neendima zomkhosi weSudeten kunye neePoles, phakathi kwezinye izinto.

Ngelixa iinkokeli zezopolitiko zokwenyani ezifana noHitler, uChamberlain, kunye noMhlekazi u-Osmund Cleverly zibonakaliswa ngokubonakalayo kuyo yonke ifilimu, abona baphambili baphambili uLegat noHartmann bayintsomi.

Kufuneka Ufunde: Ukuphelisa iNkcazelo kunye noPhononongo lweMunich: uMda weMfazwe (2021) bhanyabhanya

Nangona kunjalo, UAdam ukusuka eTrott ukuya eSolz kwaye AL Rowse kuthiwa ziphembelele abalinganiswa.

Trott wayengunozakuzaku waseJamani owayefunda kwiYunivesithi yaseOxford. Kamva wasebenzela iOfisi Yezangaphandle yaseJamani yaye wayeluchasa ngokuphandle ulawulo lobuzwilakhe lwamaNazi. UHartmann ubonisa zonke ezi nkalo zobomi bukaTrott.

UAlfred Leslie Rowse , kwelinye icala, wayengumbhali nombhali-mbali waseBritani owafumana i-scholarship Oxford kwaye wayenomsebenzi omfutshane wezopolitiko.

Ngexesha labo e-Oxford, uRowse noTrott, njengoHartmann noLegat, babengabahlobo abasondeleyo. URowse, ngokungafaniyo noLegat, akazange asebenze njengonobhala weNkulumbuso okanye kwindawo efanayo.

Ngaphandle kwabalinganiswa ababini abayintsomi, ifilimu ibonisa ukudibana kukaHitler noChamberlain. Uninzi lonxibelelwano lwabo lusekwe ngokwembali, lubonisa ukuthathela ingqalelo kwababhali kwiinkcukacha kunye nophononongo olucokisekileyo.

' UMunich: uMda weMfazwe ‘Ngumxube onamandla wembali kunye nentsomi, zonke izinto ezijongwayo. Impumelelo yayo iza kubuchule bayo bokusebenzisa iinyani ukudala imeko-bume exineneyo nenomtsalane ngemvo yongxamiseko ebonisa isiphithiphithi sezopolitiko sexesha elisibonakalisayo.

Umgangatho, kwelinye icala, uxhomekeke kubalinganiswa abangeyonyani ukulawula isiphithiphithi sobunzima obubangelwa ziimbono ezahlukeneyo zezopolitiko kunye neminqweno.

Ngenxa yoko, kungcono ukucinga ngefilimu njengokuhlaziywa kwembali.