Uphengululo lukaSeth MacFarlane's I-Orville ikulo, kwaye zilapho… Akulunganga

Seth MacFarlane ’s Inkwenkwezi yetrek Umboniso ophefumlelweyo, IOrville , amatyala kwiFox ngale Cawa, kwaye uphononongo lwangaphambili lweziqendu ezithathu zokuqala ziphumile. Ngelixa umboniso wawukhona kuthengiswa njenge Inkwenkwezi yetrek incopho , ecebisa ukubakho kwento enokubakho (ukuba uMacFarlane angabuthintela ubuhlanga / ubuhlanga / ubundlobongela obuqhelekileyo) ngokonwaba Galaxy Ukufuna -equeque, kuyabonakala ukuba itonally inzima ngakumbi kunaleyo.

Umboniso ngokumangalisayo udibanisa uburharha be-glib yeMacFarlane kunye nemizamo yokunyaniseka, nethemba le-sci-fi show- kwaye, mhlawumbi ngokungothusiyo, kubonakala ngathi ayisebenzi.

Uliz Shannon Miller, IndieWire

Luhlobo lomboniso olunokuvakala luzinzile njengehlaya lesiqingatha seyure… Kodwa eyona nto yothusayo IOrville kuba uninzi lwabantu kukuba yiyure ubude, kwaye ngokusisiseko ayinamdla ekubeni liqhula. Ezininzi kakhulu Orville izigcawu zivele zife ngalo mzuzu, kuba umdlalo ohlekisayo kaMacFarlane njengombhali (wabhala umqhubi wenqwelomoya, ubuncinci) kuthetha ukuba akakwazi ukuphepha ukubhala iziqhulo. Kodwa lo mboniso ufuna ngokwenene ukuba yi-adventure ye-sci-fi, ngoko umdlalo wokudlala udlalwa ngokugqithiseleyo, okanye ungadlalwa nhlobo. Emva kokubukela owona mboniso, iinjongo zawo zacaca: USeth wayefuna ukubangukapteni weU.S.S. Ishishini. Kwaye uFox wamvumela ukuba ayenze.

UChris Barton, iLos Angeles Times

Waziwa kakhulu kwimiboniso bhanyabhanya ekrwada Umfana wosapho kwaye Utata waseMelika! kunye neetoni ezifanayo Umxholo , Iindlela ezizigidi zokufa eNtshona kwaye, ubukhulu becala ngokwahlukana, i-stint ka-2013 ibamba ii-Oscars, iMacFarlane ayisiyiyo ukhetho olucacileyo lweyure, uthotho lobude kuthotho Inkwenkwezi yetrek , Into ecacileyo isondele entliziyweni yakhe. Ukungakwazi ukulinganisela igumbi lakhe lamavili elinomlilo okhawulezayo kunye neemfuno zokubalisa amabali IOrville Umhlaba.

Kodwa ingxaki ngakumbi kukutshintsha kweethoni eziza nokuzalisa iyure ngohlobo lomdlalo weqonga ekufuneka uxhase amanqaku orchestra Inkwenkwezi yetrek Ukuhlonela ngelixa uhlala ne-MacFarlane ekhangelekile, ukukhangela ukuhleka okuhlekisayo.

Kukho uvakalelo olungenakuphepheka lokuba uMacFarlane akangekhe athathe isigqibo sokuba umboniso wakhe uyipropu okanye yimbeko. Ayiphumelelanga ukuzama ukubamba imigca yomibini.

UCaroline Framke, Vox

IOrville ayikho, njengoko kuvela, Galaxy Ukufuna -style spoof Fox sele ithengisa kwiintengiso zayo. Inyaniso, IOrville ayihlekisi ngokukodwa, kokubini kuyilo kunye nokungafaneleki ngengozi. Endaweni yoko, kukuhlonela okungaqhelekanga ngokuthe ngqo Inkwenkwezi yetrek oko kubonakala kungavumi kangako.

IOrville ayisiyi a Inkwenkwezi yetrek ukukhawuleza - yinto Inkwenkwezi yetrek Ukuqhekeka okungenalo nofifi lokuba wenzeni ngohlobo lwayo loburharha.

Akukho mathandabuzo ukuba IOrville Ingangcono njengesiqingatha seyure ehlekisayo, ukuba kungenxa yokuba kuyacaca kwisiqingatha sokuqala ukuba iMacFarlane ayinalwazi lokugcwalisa imizuzu engama-40 yosasazo lukamabonwakude. Imiboniso idonsa kwimizuzu engaphaya kokuphela kwendalo, kwaye ngesiqendu sesithathu, indibaniselwano eyahlukileyo yabalinganiswa baqala nje ukuba nengxoxo efanayo kabini.

IOrville Imizamo enyanisekileyo yokungqubana kokuhambelana nentlalo kunye nesimbo sikaMacFarlane esiqhelekileyo se-glib

U-Ira Madison III, Isilwanyana Semihla ngemihla

Ngesizathu esithile, umboniso unyuselwa njengohlobo oluthile lwe Inkwenkwezi yetrek spoof, kodwa ayinayo loo minqweno. Ukuba uzibona ubukele IOrville , uya kujonga i-mediocre Inkwenkwezi yetrek fanfiction ifakwa ziqhulo ezimbi.

Ngenxa yokuba umboniso uyiyure kwaye ayisiyofomathi yesiqingatha seyure kaMacFarlane, iziqhulo zihlala embindini kwaye azingeni ndawo. Umboniso awungomdlalo ukuze iziqhulo zingakhi; zibakho nje kwisithuba (mhlawumbi sisikweko sendawo). Kodwa umboniso awuyiyo idrama efanelekileyo nokuba, kuba akukho nanye kwimigangatho ephezulu kakhulu.

Akukho nto ininzi ethembisayo malunga nayo IOrville nokuba yeyiphi. Ixhomekeke kwiingcinga ezigudileyo njengendoda esebenza nzima kunye nenkosikazi ekhathazayo, ibabeka kwimeko ye-sci-fi.

U-Erik Adams, iklabhu ye-AV

IOrville ayinakuba zizo zonke iintlobo zemiboniso okwangoku, kuba akuqinisekanga ukuba loluphi uhlobo lomboniso IOrville kungumbindi wayo. Injenge-amorphous njenge-glob eluhlaza enovakalelo ethe tyaba kwiipaseji zenqanawa kwaye yathetha ngelizwi likaNorm Macdonald.

IOrville ku I-Star Trek: Isizukulwana esilandelayo Intoni Umfana wosapho ku IiSimpson kwaye Iindlela ezizigidi zokufa eNtshona kwakufuneka Izihlalo ezivuthayo : Ayililo inqaku lokwenyani, kwaye ayilingisi ngendlela engaqhelekanga, kodwa into enenkangeleko efanayo kunye nokuziva okufanayo kodwa ngomphefumlo owahlukileyo. Kukho konke ukunyaniseka kwayo, icala elihlekisayo le- IOrville , icala elimisa incoko yokubeka izimvo ngesenzo, livela njengokuthatha ipiss. Imbeko kunye noburharha ayizizo iipropati ezikhethekileyo kumboniso onje, kodwa lulungelelwaniso olunobunono. IOrville ayinabuthathaka, ayilungelelananga, kwaye yingxelo yomdali ebonisa ukuba ngekhe ibekho.

(Umfanekiso obonisiweyo nge-screengrab ye-FOX's IOrville ukuya )