Ukuba iDarth Vader inokuHlawulelwa, Kutheni uKylo Ren?

kylo ren kunye nedarth vader

Njengomsindo kunye nentetho ejikeleze Ukunyuka kweSkywalker ikhula, ndiye ndazibuza ukuba ngekunjani ukuba besinayo imithombo yeendaba zentlalo kwaye olu hlobo lwe fandom ebonakalayo emva ngo 1983 ngaphambi kokukhutshwa Ukubuya kweJedi ? Ngaba bekuya kubakho iimfazwe zeenqanawa? Ukucinga ngoLuka kunye okanye ngabazali bokwenene bakaLeia? Yintoni eyayiza kuthetha ngayo ngoDarth Vader phambi kwefilimu apho ahlawulelwe khona?

Zininzi iindlela zokufumana Idabi leenkwenkwezi abalandeli bayaphikisana, kodwa kuninzi lwabasetyhini, izangqa eziqhubekekayo endizibukeleyo (kodwa ndingathathi nxaxheba ngokobuqu) Ndivakalelwa kukuba yenye yeendlela zokuqalisa ingxoxo-mpikiswano kukuba uKylo Ren, aka Ben Solo, ufanelekile uhlobo oluthile lokuhlengwa (okanye iBendemption njengoko uninzi lwabalandeli luyibiza njalo).

Ndikhe ndabona abantu bebiza abo bathanda uKylo njengomlinganiswa okanye bamthumele naye nabani na onobuhlanga kunye nabanazi-abaxhasi kunye nabaxolisi abaxolayo. Ukuthi ucinga ukuba unakho okanye, okubi ngakumbi, kufuneka ahlangulwe kunje ngengxabano. Kwimeko yezopolitiko apho amaNazi kunye nabaphathi abamhlophe babuyela umva, kulula kakhulu ukwenza loo nto eKylo. Umele ukuvela kwakhona kwe-fascism kwindalo yonke kwaye wabulala uHan Solo-utata wakhe! - ke, ewe, umele yonke into esiyithiyileyo. Kutheni le nto kufanelekile afumane naluphi na uhlobo lwenkululeko?

UAdam Driver njengoKylo Ren kwiiMfazwe zeNkanyezi: IJedi yokugqibela

Kodwa ngaba iDarth Vader yahlukile ngasemva ngemini? Ngaba uyazi, ungcungcuthekise uLeia Ithemba elitsha kwaye kwakhona vuthela iplanethi (abaphulaphuli ngo-1983 kwakungamashumi eminyaka kude kufumaniseke ukuba naye wabulala iqela leentsana!). Ndicinga ukuba unokuphikisa ukuba uBukhosi abukho njengamaNazi ngokucacileyo kwiimboniso ezimbalwa zokuqala? Ingayiyo? Elinye lawona mabali makhulu asilelayo Idabi leenkwenkwezi bekusoloko ukuba uBukhosi abubi nje kuba bubukhosi. Oko kuyasebenza kodwa asikaze sibone ukuba ukuwa kunye nokunyuka kunye nokuwa kwedemokhrasi yegalactic kubuchaphazela njani ubomi obuqhelekileyo kude kube IJedi yokugqibela .

Sekunjalo, iDarth Vader imele i-shorthand yazo zonke izinto ezimbi nezimbi kwi-Empire eya kuyo Ukubuya kweJedi . Wayengumbulali okhohlakeleyo, owoyikisayo, nokuba wayengutata kaLuka. Wayengoyena mntu ubalaseleyo kwifilimu kwaye I-fascist ngexesha apho iinkokheli zethu ezikhethiweyo kunye nelizwe bekwisivumelwano esithuthuzelayo nesihlangeneyo sokuba ama-fascists ayengalunganga. Ukanti wahlangulwa. Wafa esenza okuhle.

Khawufane ucinge ukuba oku kungoku kwaye abalandeli bakaVader bacebisa ukuba uMphathiswa Wokunyanzela-abo basebenza naye bafumane isiphelo esonwabisayo. Ndicinga ukuba abantu bebeza kulukhupha olo nzima nangakumbi kunoluvo lokuba uKylo angafumana ithuba lokutshintsha (okanye awange uRey okanye bobabini). U-Kylo Ren ungumtshatsheli ontsonkothileyo ngokwasemphefumlweni kunye nomlinganiswa ongaqondakaliyo kunoDarth Vader - sibona ubomi bakhe bangaphakathi kwaye sifumana okuninzi kwimpikiswano yakhe. Usete ngakumbi ngentlawulelo kunokuba iVader yayi… ke kutheni le nto sinomsindo malunga nalo mbono?

Njengoko kuxoxiwe ekuqaleni kwale veki, kubonakala ngathi Ukunyuka kweSkywalker w Ndiza kugcina uKylo kunye neVader njengelinye nje ixhoba lokukhohlisa kukaPalpatine, eli… meh. Kodwa ingxelo ngokuqinisekileyo imisele uBen Solo uhlobo oluthile lokujika kunye nokuhlengwa kwimigca efanayo nopopu wokugqibela kaPalpatine. Ayothusi loo nto, Idabi leenkwenkwezi kuthathelwa ingqalelo ulingano olulinganayo, ngokufuthi kube kokonakalisa. Kodwa abantu abakayithandi.

Ekuqaleni, kubonakala ngathi kwa ingcinga yokuhlangulwa, okanye yomntu ofana noAnakin okanye uKylo ohleli kwindawo engwevu yokuziphatha, ichasene nokuziphatha Idabi leenkwenkwezi Oku kuninzi malunga nobabini obucacileyo bokukhanya kunye nobumnyama. Kodwa… nguSith kuphela osebenza ngokugqibeleleyo. Idabi leenkwenkwezi , ngokoluvo lwam, imalunga nokuba zingqongqo kangakanani, iikhowudi zokuziphatha ezingalalanisiyo ezenza izinto zibe mbi ngakumbi, kwaye indlela eyenza ilizwe libe ngcono ngayo ithemba . Kwaye elo themba-lokuba kukho okuhle nkqu nakweyona mlinganiswa imbi- yiyo egcina usuku.

Ihlabathi kunye nendlela fandoms ukugxeka nokuhlalutya imithombo yeendaba itshintshe kakhulu ukusukela ngo 1983. Asisaboni nje ibali njengebali kwakhona, sijonga into enokuthi ithi malunga noluntu kunye nehlabathi lethu. Uninzi lwabalandeli lucinga ukuba amajelo osasazo afuna ukumela uhlobo oluthile lokuziphatha okugqibeleleyo malunga nendlela abacinga ukuba izinto kufanele ukuba zibe ngayo, endaweni yokungaqondakali kunye nobunzima bendlela izinto eziyiyo ngokwenene. Oko kuziphendukela kwemvelo kulungile kwaye kubi.

UAdam Driver njengoKylo Ren ejonge iDarth Vader

Sikwimzuzu yenkcubeko apho awona mazwi aphezulu emacaleni omabini okwahlukana kwezopolitiko engafuni ukuba sibone naziphi na iindawo ezingwevu okanye sive imfesane ngabo babonwa ngathi baswele isimilo, kodwa yingozi kanye la mabali alumkisa ngayo. Kulula ukoyika, ube nomsindo, ube nentiyo xa kuziwa kwabo singavumelani nabo okanye singabaqondiyo, kodwa ukuba senza njalo… sizibeka emngciphekweni wokuba mbi. Ukuba siphikisa ukuba uKylo akakufanelanga ukuhlawulelwa, okanye ubuncinci, ithuba lokwenza into elungileyo ngandlela thile ... sinokulahleka yonke ingongoma yale saga yemiboniso bhanya-bhanya esithoba.

Andikwazi ukuthetha ukuba siza kubona ntoni xa iRise of Skywalker ibetha ithiyetha kwiveki ezayo. Kodwa ndicinga ukuba iyahambelana nayo yonke into efike ngaphambili, siza kubona ukujika eKylo kolunye uhlobo. Kwaye ukuba oko kuyenzeka… kulungile. Ayisiyomdlalo bhanyabhanya othi amaNazi alungile, kodwa asinike ithemba lokuba nokuba oyena mntu ubhedayo angangcono. Kwaye ndilungile kuloo nto.

(imifanekiso: Disney / LucasFilm)

Ngaba ufuna amanye amabali anje? Yiba ngumbhalisi kwaye uxhase indawo!

-UMary Sue unemigaqo-nkqubo engqongqo yokuphawula engavumiyo, kodwa ayikhawulelwanga, ukuthukwa nabani na , Intiyo nentetho egonyamelayo. —